Social Construction
Social construction is basically
society labeling people and putting them into specific groups, (gender, race,
age) and giving them meaning. Hanfler says "Constructionist theories
emphasizes that what we label deviant depends on context and how we interpret
the meaning of deviance". What that means is, each society has their own
rules on what is deviant behavior, and therefore, they have their own way of
socially constructing. The section of Hanfler's writing that we read focused on
tattoos and how they're interpreted. For instance, Hanfler asks "When are
tattoos considered "art" and when are they symbolic of gang
membership or other identities?"
I most closely related this to the
reading "The Social Construction of Gender" by Judith Lorber. Lorber
focuses on the fact that gender is a learned thing, it’s not something you’re
born with. She believes that social construction starts at birth, because
parents dress and treat their children differently depending on their sex. The
main connection between these two readings comes from this quote from Lorber, “Western
societies have only two genders, "man" and "woman." Some
societies have three genders- men, women, and berdaches or hiiras or xaniths.
Berdaches, hijras, and xaniths are biological males who behave, dress, work,
and are treated in most respects as social women; they are therefore not men,
nor are they female women; they are, in our language, "male women."
There are Mrican and American Indian societies that have a gender status called
manly hearted Women- biological females who work, marry, and parent as men;
their social status is "female men"”. This quote shows that some
behavior we, in Western Cultures, would define as deviant and would socially
construction in a negative way, is much more accepted in some other societies. Would
our society be able to adapt to adding a third gender the way other societies
do?
I think social construction will
always be a problem. People shouldn’t be defined by matters out of their
control such as race, age, and gender. There’s no real way to control these
things because they’re so deeply engraved into our culture. The one text I didn’t
agree with was, “Vershawn Ashanti Young: Should Writer’s Use They Own English?”
I personally believe that the way you write in class or in a professional
atmosphere, and the way you talk with your friends should be two distinctively separate
dialects that shouldn’t intertwine unless that is what the assignment calls
for. Also, when Young says “Lord, lord, lord! Where do I begin, cuz this man
sho tryin to take the nation back to a time when we were less tolerant of
linguistic and racial differences. Yeah, I said racial difference, tho my man
Stan be talkin explicitly bout language differences. The two be intertwined” I
disagree. I don’t believe that the way you write or talk has much to do with
your race. Instead, I think the main factor is your level of education.
I agree with what you said about it being so hard to change our culture. It is deeply engraved in our society. Since this is something that we have grown up with and there are so many different components of it, it is definitely going to take a while. Even if it does change, I agree with you that it may always be a problem. It is similar to racism in that people are still not completely accepting the change. I think someday, gender and sex will be something that people are more comfortable talking about, but there will still be individuals not agreeing with it, which is something that will always be in every society.
ReplyDeleteWriting in a class or professional setting as opposed to the way you talk with your friends should, as you said, use two distinctly separate dialects. I agree with you, and not Vershawn Young, because there needs to be a standard language to be used in writing that can be easily read and analyzed across cultures. Another interesting point that you brought up was the question posed at the end of the 2nd paragraph. I think we are already starting to see how our culture is adapting to a third gender, with the term transgendered becoming more widespread in our society. Society is slowly, but steadily becoming more accepting of this term and the people associated with it, and at some point in the future, I think the third gender will become as accepted in our society as it is in societies describes by Lorber.
ReplyDeleteI really liked what you said about how Lorber's insight about gender being a learned thing. I completely agree. This is also why boys act mean to girls, when they're little. One of the parents, generally the father, says things to make the boys seem superior and stronger than girls, so the boys feel the need to talk down to girls. It's so interesting to me because, like you said, no one is born with that. It's created through the way their parents treat them and what they say to them.
ReplyDelete